I'm gonna have to disagree with this one.
RDR was a crappy game.
It was pretty, that's a given.
It had smooth mechanics, absolutely gorgeous settings, interesting characters and top class animations and voice acting.
But the actual gameplay was incredibly repetitive, traveling was an absolute pain and it's story felt like a deja vu.
To explain:
The gameplay was repetitive cause just about every mission turned out to be travel by horse with someone else in snail pace to destination, do some shooting with the repeater or rifle as shotgun's are crap in long range combat, sniper rifle is crap on consoles, rope doesn't do any damage, and enemies are too spread out to use grenades or molotovs.
So it just became a repetitive shootout all the time.
Now now, there are different missions, like that one where you at first have to sneak kill people with throwing knifes.
But those missions are far apart and far too few.
Next is hunting, at first I loved it, going out into the wild, seeing a coyote and hunting it down. Phun tymes.
But then it became repetitive, boring and unrewarding.
Same with picking flowers.
The economy was broken as all you needed was pistol and rifle ammo which you got off of bodies by looting.
The minigames only served as distractions and quite frankly boring distractions. If I wanted to play poker I could just do that online, as for the other minigames like throwing horse shoes or whatever they're called, couldn't they just have developed them as online minigames or something? I just find minigames like that to be a pointless waste of time.
And then we had horses... They traveled way too slow, had to follow paths to get anywhere in a decent amount of time (And Mexico's path layout was horrible) and the damn [censored] clicking on the A button that Rockstar games have to do is annoying as [censored] hell and just ends up huring my thumb. (xbox)
So click click click click click click hold.... click click click click click click hold.... click click click click click click hold.... :shudders:
Now as to the story, what the hell am I talking about right?
Well, how many times haven't Marshton or whatever his name was said "Help me or I'm leaving"?
He said that in next to every mission I can remember, yet he, a former hardcoe bandit, just took it like the little [censored] that he is.
So after the first couple of them I started wondering "Well, are you gonna do anything or just whine?"
Turns out he liked whining and being dominated by everyone. Weirdo....
And Mexico was the worst part. Was some time since I played it but first I was after this first guy, Frank or Tom or Bub.
And when I finally get into that damn fort of his he hightails over to Mexico where I get dragged into a storyline that felt like a giant filler and all of the sudden they throw the next gang member at me and Marschmalleow starts looking for him instead.
And then when I finally find this new guy, Enrique or whatever, he gets captures *snaps fingers* like that. The pacing in Mexico's storyline was the abolute worst.
And the missions, again "Help me or I'm leaving" happened constantly over two opposing sides which I had no interest in.
And both sides always said "yeah, we're gonna tell you where Ricardo is, juuuuust after you do this one tiiiiiny thing for us."
But it wasn't just one tiny thing now was it.... It was dozens of medium to large sized things.. Dragged out for no reason.
So the storyline? It was like they had a great western story in mind at first, but when they started writing it out they figured "Oh crap, it's too short for a Rockstar game!" and they padded it out.
It's gameplay was boring.
Mars-Man felt completely out of character as to what he was supposed to portray.
Traveling svcked.
Economy broken.
Weapons unnecessary.
Red Cool Eyes With Slo-mo unbalanced.
Dragged out storyline.
It was pretty, the first and third part were great in it's cinematic aspects.
But the gameplay ultimately failed to deliver challenging combat or varying missions and the whole Mexico part was just absolutetly dreadful in every aspect.
RDR,
for me, is an overrated piece of crap.
It's expansion on the other hand was a blast.
Not for it's brilliant writing, that was cheesy, but a fun kind of cheesy, like Braindead or Bad Taste.
Not for having varying missions, those were pretty much "kill stuff", but it was a simplistic fun which also challenged me with waves of the undead, all of which had their own type of combat type apart from the vanilla game where every enemy used rifle or repeater.
It's storyline was also pretty straight to the point, it wasn't long but it didn't have to be, it had what was necessary for the storyline, and I liked that.
It's animations, voice acting and scenery was still all just about perfect
And it's distractions also served a purpose, like finding the four horses of the apocalypse, or killing the Chupacabra.
So Undead Nightmare? I had a freaking blast playing that. It was a really fun, challenging, beautiful game.
But RDR, I honestly don't see why it's so highly praised.