» Tue Jun 15, 2010 12:00 pm
Actually, to all the naysayers, I was done with disc two after about 11 to 12 hours. That was doing about 10-15 side missions to that point (they get repetitive as well). The fact is, the game is just easy and repetitive. Its not hard to beat it in a day. I actually had to slow down just to get somthing out of it. So yes, the game is short with little to no replay value. I could see 100% this in about a fifth, or a sixth of the time it took to 100% Red Dead, which took me a week to do. I guess Im just a great detective. So I stick with the "rental only" tag. The game is 25-30 hours if you 100% it and your slow. That is not worth 63 bucks to me.
Then again, my standards are probably higher than most of yours. I only buy RPGs, Strategy and some sports titles. Basically games I can get 100+ hours out of. I rent everything else. Even if L.A. was 40-50 hours, I couldn't advocate buying it, since there's just really no replay value. Other than playing it again a year or so down the road after the particulars of each case begin to get hazy. Its like a choose your own adventure book. Its fun while it lasts, but there's no reason to play it again since you know exactly what to do. I also go extremely hard on games, can and will play them all day and night. Im just core like that.