Oblivion and Astrology

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:31 am

Hello. My name is Renee, and I'd like to talk with you about some of my most recent insights into this game, Oblivion. The insights I'm going to discuss can be applied to other Bethesda games, or to any such game if your character has a specfic recorded creation-time & date. A little background now...

When I was in my teens, trying to figure out alot of things about myself that seemed f'd up, someone (my mom I think) turned me onto astrology. From then on, my life was never the same. Not only did I learn alot about myself and others, I became a better person overall. I learned that alot of the weird, antisocial things I was into as a kid were neatly symbolized (somehow) in my horoscope. I did tons of reading on the subject; bought lots of books. I have done people's charts and read Tarot cards for money. I even read for the Tarot Card Hotline back in the late '80s for awhile! I tried to practice witchcraft (which I'm simply not cut out for) and practiced meditation (which I am cut out for). Now that I'm in my 40s, I don't actively pursue alot of this new-agey stuff so much like I used to. But I occasionally delve back into it.

Some of you may think I've gone mental, while others might find some insight here. But I have really pushed the boundaries of what a PC (Player Character) is all about lately. I did a horoscope...for one of my characters. :)


For those of you who are unfamiliar, astrology can be a useful key for gaining insights into ourselves, or it can be used as a method of divination (looking towards the future). Those are the 2 main uses. Now I'm not talking about the sort of astrology that's found in a common newspaper or magazine (which takes only a person's Sun sign into account), nor am I talking of the in-game character Starsign, I'm talking about actually making a full horoscope, cast from the moment my character was "born".

...So this means I noted the exact time (down to the minute) and date of when she showed up on-screen in jail at the beginning of the game. Then I did a horoscope for her using this information. I didn't read her horoscope right away; matter of fact I actually didn't read it until last week, which is about 3 months after her creation.

The reason it's so interesting is: alot of her personality traits (as I imagine them to be) actually match-up with the horoscope. From my perspective, it is downright spooky at times.

...Here goes. There's alot of text below, and I don't expect everyone to agree or understand it all, because there's alot of concepts that may be new to you, but I'll try my best. But those of you who know anything about horoscopes should be able to get what I'm saying (assuming you agree).


NAME: Dyan phor a'Cauze

AGE: 25

RACE: Nord

CLASS: Paladin (custom class)

ALIGNMENT: Lawful Good

CREATED: May 17, 2010 at 6:08 pm



Press the link below to see Dyan's horoscope.

http://interactive.0800-horoscope.com/cgi-bin/astro/natal0800?name=Dyan+&six=f&d1day=17&d1month=5&d1year=2010&d1hour=18&d1min=18&adjust=0&citylist=Baltimore,+MD+(24),+United+States&lang=en



The link above takes one to the computer/internet-generated horoscope description. Sometimes, it's consistent with what Dyan is all about, but other times it's not. Computer-generated horoscopes are like this; kinda wishy-washy. I think it's impossible to truely interpret a horoscope unless other extenuating factors are known. In other words, the best astrology is performed when an actual human is doing the interpreting. So I've provided my own interpretations.

Like the computer's text says, the 3 main personality traits a person has are usually represented by his or her Ascendant, Sun, and Moon signs. Whatever planets rule the ascendant, sun, and moon signs also are often important (I'll explain the concept of ruling later).

The Ascendant is sort of like our "mask". It's the personality trait we use, for instance, when we're just meeting somebody new, or if we feel uncomfortable in some situation. It's the basic way we present ourself to the world-at-large.

Ever notice how some people often behave much differently at first than they do once you get to know them? While other people are much more consistent from the time you meet them to the time you get to know them? Whatever sign is on the Ascendant colors that first side of our personality, while the sun and moon (sometimes other planets and factors) show the rest.

Dyan's Ascendant (or first house...there are a total of 12 houses and the Ascendant is the first one) falls in Virgo, an Earth sign with mutable quality. Mutable means changeable, as in: here's someone who's constantly trying to adapt to current circumstances. Many real-life Virgos (or people with alot of Virgo in their chart) I've known have a crafty quality to them; often they're good with their hands (or they try to be) and can be very or somewhat down-to-earth. Not always...it depends. Some of them are very high-strung...it all depends on what else is going on in their horoscope (as well as how they were brought up and other environmental factors).

The Sun sign is our core, (as is the Moon) and both of these symbolize who we really are inside and outside (as opposed to the Ascendant, which is often more of a mask). Dyan's Sun is Taurus, which is the fixed-Earth sign. "Fixed" means (obviously) unchangeable, and many Tauruses I've known definitely are very patient, easy-going, laid-back, but also stubborn and fix-minded.

Dyan the Paladin is definitely stubborn and fixed-minded, but usually in a good way. She's currently after the KotN quests, Fighter's Guild quests, and various independant tasks here and there. Any task with overall good intent she's up for. But basically: she wants to save Cyrodiil's fair lands from evil and will stop at nothing until it's done! She will also do the Main Quests at some point.

...It takes a woman of determination here, not somebody who's gonna give up halfway down the path. Taurus Sun combined with an Ascendant in Virgo: here we have someone who prefers working with concreteness, (rather than abstract concepts) who is fix-minded, but also has the ability to balance this with adaptability.

An Earth-type person (as Dyan is) is rarely rash in his or her decisions, as a fire-type person would be. Nor is she too emotional or intellectual (Water and Air) in her approach. Though she never sneaks when approaching an enemy, neither is she too rash. When adventuring, she plans everything beforehand if she can. THEN she rushes in. But she never sneaks. She always presents herself to her enemy in an honest way, and she wants her enemies to KNOW who they're dealing with. Again, this is a person who deals with concreteness. Who is more hands-on and immediate in her environment.

The Sun is the outward, shining part of most people's personality, while the Moon is the inner, reflective part. Inside emotions and all that. Some people don't have very strong Moons in modern society, while others do. People with stronger Moons (even guys) usually are very sensitive. In our society, they either hide this sensitivity (or try to) or they're very vocal about it. Depends.

Dyan's Moon is in Cancer, a water sign with cardinal qualities. What's interesting is; "Moon in Cancer" is just about as emotional of a person as you could find. Although I don't picture Dyan as being this crying, laughing, mood-driven being (her more practical Sun and Ascendant signs contradict this often), she is very caring. Very empathetic. Very good at seeing life thru the eyes of the unfortunate. ALWAYS gives a coin to a beggar (especially if they're older and weathered), and she never turns away a quest in which a weaker person can't get something done. Her motivation here is often empathy. Not money (although many earthy people tend to be materialistic), not fame, and not ego. She can't help but care constantly for the good people of Cyrodiil when or if they're down-trodden, a reaction shown by Moon in Cancer. She then uses this caring approach when she moves toward action (more on this later).

...I also like to think that when she was younger, Dyan had problems keeping her emotions in check, resulting in some problems as a kid & teen. Nothing too drastic, no murders or nothing like that, but she seems to have been somewhat of a trouble-maker in her youth. But she would get into this trouble while trying to perform a good act. This is how she wound up in jail, but I'm not sure of the full story yet. I do know that as an advlt, she's managed to channel these emotions into something constructive (again, she's after the Crusader's relics, she's into helping the unfortunate, bla bla bla).



...What gets interesting now is that the planet Saturn is in her first house/Ascendant. So she's got Saturn in Virgo. In astrological terms, whatever planet sits in your first house is often a very huge force affecting your personality (first house is all about "you", your personality, how you present yourself to the world).

...The reason it's interesting that her first house has Saturn sitting in it is that Saturn is the planet of discipline. Of seriousness. People with strong Saturns are often successful in our money-driven society, simply because they're often tireless status-seekers. Or they're workaholics. Even poorer Capricorns I've known are often very dependable workers.

Although Dyan is not in this business of adventuring for the money, she does have a very serious side to her. Matter of fact, even before I did her horoscope, I imagined her as this very serious type who never jokes and rarely cracks a smile. She's VERY determined at her "job".


Bottom line: she is after success. Not the fame, attention, or money it can garner. She likes feeling important. As she becomes inevitably famous throughout the land of Tamriel, it won't be her money or her ego that's on display, it'll be her good works. But performing good works on such a huge scale as KotN (and other quests, no matter how small)requires determination, planning, and seriousness (in Dyan's eyes, anyways). I find it interesting that even before I did her horoscope, I was picturing all of this...the seriousness, the determined persona. I wasn't picturing somebody who's ill-focused, lazy, or a party animal.


The next point of interest: Venus. In typical astrology, the planet Venus is said to rule one's approach to pleasure, their ability to get along with others, love, attractivness, vanity, etc. It often can also indicate what sort of spouse or lover one feels comfortable with or attracting. Well, none of this applies to Oblivion (vanilla, anyways) because it's impossible to have a lover in this game who actually sticks around, adores you (well...), and eventually starts nagging you. :( But I'm looking into Venus anyways, here. Why?

Each sign has a planet that rules it. Cancer is ruled by the Moon, for instance, while Leo is ruled by the Sun. Since Dyan is a Taurus (her Sun is in Taurus), her persona is going to be colored by whatever sign Venus is in, because Venus rules the sign of Taurus.

So Venus was in Gemini the moment Dyan was created. Gemini is an air sign (strongly intellectual) that has mutable (changeable/adaptable) qualities. Geminis, or people with alot of Gemini in their charts, are often good with words. Gabby. Social. They're also often multi-tasking fiends. Several projects going at once, none of them getting finished sometimes! Several books being read at the same time, etc. etc. Geminis sometimes have lots of diversity, but not a whole lot of organization.

While I don't picture Dyan as a super-social, super intellectual human, she does do quite alot of talking (and listening) to various NPCs, usually with her serious intent. And she definitely feels comfortable having several quests (i.e. projects) going at once, the difference is she's got the determiation (Saturn in Virgo in the 1st house, as well as Sun and Mercury in Taurus) to see these projects thru.

She's also always travelling, and several people I've known IRL who have alot of Gemini in their charts are the types who "can't sit still" very long! That's Dyan to some extent (especially while she's questing), although all that Earth in her chart (the Taurus Sun especially, as well as Mercury in Taurus) also gets its say, since Dyan does put aside time to relax (especially if a chapel is nearby). She loves slashing enemies, true; but she also loves just sitting in a chapel (or somewhere outside) just reading a book she's never read before. She does ALOT of reading, actually. :lol:

Next is Mars. Dyan's got Mars in Leo. More specifically, she's got Mars at 19.5 degrees of Leo. Ah, degrees. There are 30 degrees in each sign, and the planets can fall on any of these 30 degrees. Mars represents our drive, the way we channel energy towards whatever: building a house, six, accomplishing a task. Mars is all about action and war, while Venus is (typically) more about relaxing, peace, harmony, and pleasure. Obviously, whatever sign Mars falls in is going to be very important to someone who's constantly fighting.

With a Mars in Leo, here we've got someone who's somewhat leonine and bossy when she's motivated (in effect, when she's doing quests), trying to get things done. All of this is right on the money so far as Dyan goes. I always picture her SCREAMING her intent as she goes into battle: I AM DYAN PHOR a'CAUZE, AND I AM HERE TO BANISH THEE UNHOLY CREANTS FROM THIS PLACE! :D She's very valiant in this regard, very vocal, quickly aggressive once she's fighting, but she also makes mistakes at times due to these habits.

Leo is the fixed fire sign. So that means: she's stubborn, fiery, and strong-willed when in action, but also leonine. Leos are often very much like lions. They roar when they're angry, they need alot of affection, they're often very playful, too. Fire signs are often more rash and action-oriented than Water, Earth, and Air signs; the problem is they also often burn up their energy wastefully if this energy isn't channeled correctly.

Let's talk about aspects. Aspects are mathematical relationships between two planets, or between a planet and a house. Conjunctions (zero degrees), sixtiles (sixty degrees), squares (90 degrees), trines (120), inconjuncts (150), and oppositions (180) are the strongest aspects. The closer to the actual number, the stronger the energy created by the aspect; in effect, if two planets are at 29 degrees Scorpio, they'll have a stronger conjunction than if one planet is at 29 degrees but the othe is at 22. Some aspects create harmonious relationships, while others create difficult ones.


...it's not so much the "Mars in Leo" that's interesting, it's the fact that Dyan has a Mars which is square (approximately 90 degrees) to her sun. Mars is at 19.5 degrees in Leo, while the Sun is at about 26 degrees of Taurus. These are two fixed signs.

In this case, Mars square to the Sun is creating a "difficult" aspect, and the more difficult aspects generally create the most energy. In real-life, someone with such an aspect might be overly aggressive, enthusiastic, or have problems with anger management, especially since both the signs (Leo and Taurus) are fixed and therefore stubborn. On the other hand, another person with this aspect might be able to turn this aggression around into something positive. A lot of energy is created by a square like this one, not only because both planets are in fixed signs, but also because one is earth and one is fire. Dyan is a heroic-type of Paladin, very energetic once she's out "in the field" and being called to action; and alot of this is due to the fact that she's very driven, which is symbolized by the relationship between these 2 planets in her chart.


...that's enough for now. If this thread doesn't get locked :lol: I'll write more insights as I study the rest of the planets Dyan's got in her chart. Good journey to you!
User avatar
daniel royle
 
Posts: 3439
Joined: Thu May 17, 2007 8:44 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 7:18 am

Out of curiosity, what is the mechanism by which the stars (including the sun, obviously) and planets (other than earth) may impact a person's life?
User avatar
helen buchan
 
Posts: 3464
Joined: Wed Sep 13, 2006 7:17 am

Post » Sat Oct 03, 2009 11:23 pm

I AM DYAN PHOR a'CAUZE, AND I AM HERE TO BANISH THEE UNHOLY CREANTS FROM THIS PLACE! :D She's very valiant in this regard, very vocal, quickly aggressive once she's fighting, but she also makes mistakes at times due to these habits.

How Leo of her! :D

This is very interesting -- I'm really curious to hear what the outer planets have in store for her.
User avatar
REVLUTIN
 
Posts: 3498
Joined: Tue Dec 26, 2006 8:44 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 12:09 am

This is pretty cool. Kudos. Whenever there was something going on that was important in our lives, my ex would break out her tarot cards and "see" what was going on. We made a lot of our decisions in early advlt life, based on her readings, which seemed strangely similar to my thoughts, I wasn't big into the "readings." Every time we made a decision based on what she could discern, it was the right decision.... I like taking a backseat on the journey that is someone's life....
User avatar
Multi Multi
 
Posts: 3382
Joined: Mon Sep 18, 2006 4:07 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 7:01 am

Justt a tad curious.....can you give me a horoscope? Born in 1992, 28, April, makes me a Taurus.

Also I really wanna know alot more on the ritual birthsign, it says in some birthsign book that its powers change due too the stars, i wish that happened in-game.
User avatar
Red Bevinz
 
Posts: 3318
Joined: Thu Sep 20, 2007 7:25 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 9:01 am

Out of curiosity, what is the mechanism by which the stars (including the sun, obviously) and planets (other than earth) may impact a person's life?


Personally, I have little (personal) belief in astrology, BUT... before I drop my 2 septims on the question directly...

For a college class once (mathematics related) we had to do this project. My 2 partners and I gave our co-workers some carefully designed surveys. These people went into it blind - they had NO IDEA what we were doing, other than it was for a class that we were taking (fortunately we were all on good terms, and trusted each other. This was when I was in the military... about 1981, Augsburg, Germany).

For 1 month, they were supposed to "rate" their lives daily according to the survey questions. How did they feel, generally? For a given day, were they happy, sad, depressed, energetic, relaxed, irritible? How was their six life? Their health? Their appetite? Their mood? These questions were all coded via a sophisticated system.

We then calulated their "biorythms", and compared the results to the surveys. The results were occasionally "spooky". The one best conclusion that WE found in our sample (about 17 or 18 people as I recall), was that some people seem to *absolutely not be affected* by biorythms, or the results were inconclusive. But others not only SEEMED to be, they seemed to be STRONGLY influenced by them. I forget the percentage. It gave me cause to wonder about my view of the universe.

Note that less than 20 people is a small sample, but you "had to be there". Our surveys were very well designed, we put a lot of thought into it. The results were too strong to be a coincidence.

Now, I HAVE dabbled in astrology. My best conclusion FOR MYSELF is that is has *little* impact (or so little that it isn't very meaningful). But MAYBE it's along the lines of that old biorhythms experiment... maybe some people are more strongly influenced than others... maybe some people are more sensitive to certain events... maybe some para-mystical-supernatural "system" that is bigger than us and we can't see "touches" some people, but leaves others alone.

My "dabbling" is astrology was influenced by my very real interest in astronomy (I've made my own telescopes, written my own software, I am fascinated by celestial mechanics, and I have been into computers for years - built some of the first computer KITS with a soldering iron).

In addition to the point that I made (hopefully fairly clear), it could be that the positions of the stars and planets have no DIRECT bearing on things... they are just the indicator for the "thing" that DOES possibly have influence.

Does time stop if your watch breaks? Do the hands on your clock tell the time? REALLY? No, they don't. They are an indirect REFLECTION of the movement of time, calibrated to a system that makes sense (to most of us).
User avatar
Tom
 
Posts: 3463
Joined: Sun Aug 05, 2007 7:39 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 3:34 am

Justt a tad curious.....can you give me a horoscope? Born in 1992, 28, April, makes me a Taurus.

Also I really wanna know alot more on the ritual birthsign, it says in some birthsign book that its powers change due too the stars, i wish that happened in-game.


She also needs your PLACE of birth, and the exact time if possible. (birth certificate)
User avatar
GLOW...
 
Posts: 3472
Joined: Thu Aug 03, 2006 10:40 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:04 pm

Interesting stuff... Didnt read all of it but still :P

If I would have been a little more energic I would have found out place of birth and exact time of birth. But the school drained me from all energy.
User avatar
Victoria Bartel
 
Posts: 3325
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 10:20 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:34 am

Very cool Renee! You have certainly taken roleplaying to a higher level! While I am a Witch, I never delved much into astrology. An old girlfriend of mine did however, so much of what you say is not entirely new to me (although I am very fuzzy on it all, its been a long time!). I would love to hear more!

It reminds me of the old days when I played pen and paper RPGs, and sometimes did tarot readings for characters. On a good night, they could be quite accurate. Or the tarot reading I used for the Teresa fiction, which I used to foreshadow the end of the Oblivion Crisis.
User avatar
Joanne Crump
 
Posts: 3457
Joined: Sat Jul 22, 2006 9:44 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 8:08 am

She also needs your PLACE of birth, and the exact time if possible. (birth certificate)

Louisville, KY

and oh.....around 2:00am
User avatar
Krystina Proietti
 
Posts: 3388
Joined: Sat Dec 23, 2006 9:02 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:29 pm

Out of curiosity, what is the mechanism by which the stars (including the sun, obviously) and planets (other than earth) may impact a person's life?


I don't have a clue how it works. It's one of those things that exists somehow even though we can't see it. We overrate our brains sometimes; there's alot we can't see or detect in our world.


This is pretty cool. Kudos. Whenever there was something going on that was important in our lives, my ex would break out her tarot cards and "see" what was going on. We made a lot of our decisions in early advlt life, based on her readings, which seemed strangely similar to my thoughts, I wasn't big into the "readings." Every time we made a decision based on what she could discern, it was the right decision.... I like taking a backseat on the journey that is someone's life....


Cool. :) It's been years (like 15 years) since I've done a Taro reading. Sometimes it's just better not to know too much, know what I mean? :)

One of the mistakes people make with cards (and divination-type astrology) is they think they're "fated" to a certain path. Then they get all freaked out. I believe there are always different paths to choose. Tarot cards merely illuminate some of them.
User avatar
X(S.a.R.a.H)X
 
Posts: 3413
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 2:38 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 6:43 am

I don't have a clue how it works. It's one of those things that exists somehow even though we can't see it.


If it does exist and has an actual impact, surely the mechanics behind it should be discernible, right?

In any case, if you're willing I would be interested in what you could divine about me based on my information.

I was born on June 1st 1982 at roughly 6:00 AM in Dansville, NY.

Obviously this would take time from your day, so if you don't feel the urge to humor me, I certainly understand.
User avatar
jodie
 
Posts: 3494
Joined: Wed Jun 14, 2006 8:42 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 1:50 am

If it does exist and has an actual impact, surely the mechanics behind it should be discernible, right?

In any case, if you're willing I would be interested in what you could divine about me based on my information.

I was born on June 1st 1982 at roughly 6:00 AM in Dansville, NY.

Obviously this would take time from your day, so if you don't feel the urge to humor me, I certainly understand.


There's probably some new research or theories on the matter of how this stuff works, haven't really been reading up on it though. Like I said, I don't really practice it anymore, except for occasional cases like with my character. :lol:

Personally, I feel the planets are more like symbols...they don't actually send signals to us that make us who we are. :shrug: But

Justt a tad curious.....can you give me a horoscope? Born in 1992, 28, April, makes me a Taurus.

Also I really wanna know alot more on the ritual birthsign, it says in some birthsign book that its powers change due too the stars, i wish that happened in-game.




In both cases, yes I'll write up a chart, you might have to give me a few days though. :) If I'm gonna do it, it'll be private though, just to keep this thread clean from off-topic stuff.

Don't know about the Ritual starsign, sorry. I think I've only played 4 different starsigns so far.
User avatar
Agnieszka Bak
 
Posts: 3540
Joined: Fri Jun 16, 2006 4:15 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 4:37 am

Very cool Renee! You have certainly taken roleplaying to a higher level! While I am a Witch, I never delved much into astrology. An old girlfriend of mine did however, so much of what you say is not entirely new to me (although I am very fuzzy on it all, its been a long time!). I would love to hear more!

It reminds me of the old days when I played pen and paper RPGs, and sometimes did tarot readings for characters. On a good night, they could be quite accurate. Or the tarot reading I used for the Teresa fiction, which I used to foreshadow the end of the Oblivion Crisis.


Me too. I think I did tarot readings for my characters way back in the day (my D&D characters), too, but that was so long ago. I know me and my brother made rules for arcane arts, though.

I don't consider myself a true witch, but I've definitely am able to do a few limited things which I'm not speaking of publicly! I can send you a PM on that subject! I've always been able to a few limited magics, since I was a kid. But I've never been able to expand on this with actual books, ingredients, items, etc.
User avatar
Joanne Crump
 
Posts: 3457
Joined: Sat Jul 22, 2006 9:44 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 12:28 pm

One of the mistakes people make with cards (and divination-type astrology) is they think they're "fated" to a certain path. Then they get all freaked out. I believe there are always different paths to choose. Tarot cards merely illuminate some of them.


Yes, exactly. Divinations such as with tarot are designed to help a person look ahead and see the way the wind is blowing. A person always chooses their own fate. Tarot might help them decide what fate to choose, and to be prepared for what might happen.
User avatar
Kay O'Hara
 
Posts: 3366
Joined: Sun Jan 14, 2007 8:04 pm

Post » Sat Oct 03, 2009 9:44 pm

This kind of stuff isn't really my thing, but I find it cool that you took the time to do a horoscope for one of your characters.
User avatar
Tamara Dost
 
Posts: 3445
Joined: Mon Mar 12, 2007 12:20 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 7:52 am

This kind of stuff isn't really my thing, but I find it cool that you took the time to do a horoscope for one of your characters.


Thanks! And thanks to everyone who's posted so far. I didn't know what to expect when I posted this topic last nite, was really nervous about it, actually. I didn't expect everyone to agree or believe in this stuff, and I half-expected to find a bunch of flames when I showed up here today! So I'm glad everyone has been respectful. :thumbsup:



Yes, exactly. Divinations such as with tarot are designed to help a person look ahead and see the way the wind is blowing. A person always chooses their own fate. Tarot might help them decide what fate to choose, and to be prepared for what might happen.


I imagine that way back in the middle ages (when Tarot cards were supposed to have surfaced from gypsies at the time) that was the way the cards wound up being used. You get a reading, and there's nothing you can do if it says bad things!

Huzzah! ;)
User avatar
X(S.a.R.a.H)X
 
Posts: 3413
Joined: Tue Feb 20, 2007 2:38 pm

Post » Sat Oct 03, 2009 10:33 pm

No offense, but witchcraft? I think you're crazy. But still interesting.
User avatar
Roberta Obrien
 
Posts: 3499
Joined: Tue Oct 23, 2007 1:43 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 12:31 am

Personally, I have little (personal) belief in astrology, BUT... before I drop my 2 septims on the question directly...

For a college class once (mathematics related) we had to do this project. My 2 partners and I gave our co-workers some carefully designed surveys. These people went into it blind - they had NO IDEA what we were doing, other than it was for a class that we were taking (fortunately we were all on good terms, and trusted each other. This was when I was in the military... about 1981, Augsburg, Germany).

For 1 month, they were supposed to "rate" their lives daily according to the survey questions. How did they feel, generally? For a given day, were they happy, sad, depressed, energetic, relaxed, irritible? How was their six life? Their health? Their appetite? Their mood? These questions were all coded via a sophisticated system.

We then calulated their "biorythms", and compared the results to the surveys. The results were occasionally "spooky". The one best conclusion that WE found in our sample (about 17 or 18 people as I recall), was that some people seem to *absolutely not be affected* by biorythms, or the results were inconclusive. But others not only SEEMED to be, they seemed to be STRONGLY influenced by them. I forget the percentage. It gave me cause to wonder about my view of the universe.

Note that less than 20 people is a small sample, but you "had to be there". Our surveys were very well designed, we put a lot of thought into it. The results were too strong to be a coincidence.

Now, I HAVE dabbled in astrology. My best conclusion FOR MYSELF is that is has *little* impact (or so little that it isn't very meaningful). But MAYBE it's along the lines of that old biorhythms experiment... maybe some people are more strongly influenced than others... maybe some people are more sensitive to certain events... maybe some para-mystical-supernatural "system" that is bigger than us and we can't see "touches" some people, but leaves others alone.

My "dabbling" is astrology was influenced by my very real interest in astronomy (I've made my own telescopes, written my own software, I am fascinated by celestial mechanics, and I have been into computers for years - built some of the first computer KITS with a soldering iron).

In addition to the point that I made (hopefully fairly clear), it could be that the positions of the stars and planets have no DIRECT bearing on things... they are just the indicator for the "thing" that DOES possibly have influence.

Does time stop if your watch breaks? Do the hands on your clock tell the time? REALLY? No, they don't. They are an indirect REFLECTION of the movement of time, calibrated to a system that makes sense (to most of us).


Funny thing is I've never been able to fully comprehend the concept of biorhythms or numerology. Those sort of concepts are just a bit too abstract for my image-addicted mind. But wow...interesting results for that test. What was the motivation for starting the biorhythm test in the first place?



No offense, but witchcraft? I think you're crazy. But still interesting.


Lol, I'm crazy and interesting!

No seriously...there's alot that goes on that most of us (as humans) can't grasp. I've got a record of every uh...act I've performed over the years, as well as what eventually happened as an end result. :shrug: I can't make any conclusion other than my life-force or energy or whatever had something to do with that end result, something which was unseen.




Well, I will add more to this thread that's on-topic, perhaps tomorrow. WE'll see. :) I have a couple other characters whom I got a full horoscope for as well, but one of them is already "dead", and the other one is too new. I don't wanna interpret her chart until I've gotten to know her a bit more.
User avatar
IM NOT EASY
 
Posts: 3419
Joined: Mon Aug 13, 2007 10:48 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 2:51 am

Renee, I don't think you're crazy. I have a wonderful friend who is a witch. We might indeed drink from different teacups, but I have learned much from her. Can you tie astrology to TES lore?

Buffy was born at the moment of sunrise, Rains Hand, the 19th, 3E 415. In Bravil, on the second floor of The Fair Deal. So, she is born under the sign of the Mage. I don't know what Massur, Secunda and the stars above Nirn were doing at that time.

Are there any personality/temperment traits that can be suggested by her starsign of the Mage?

Are there any pure TES insights that can be gained from the astral bodies visible from Nirn?

Since the Shade of the Revenant is a sign from the sky, does it play any role in TES astrology?
User avatar
carly mcdonough
 
Posts: 3402
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2006 3:23 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 2:57 am

There's probably some new research or theories on the matter of how this stuff works, haven't really been reading up on it though. Like I said, I don't really practice it anymore, except for occasional cases like with my character. :lol:

Personally, I feel the planets are more like symbols...they don't actually send signals to us that make us who we are. :shrug: But





In both cases, yes I'll write up a chart, you might have to give me a few days though. :) If I'm gonna do it, it'll be private though, just to keep this thread clean from off-topic stuff.

Don't know about the Ritual starsign, sorry. I think I've only played 4 different starsigns so far.

Cool, if you have time that'd be great, just PM me I guess,
User avatar
christelle047
 
Posts: 3407
Joined: Mon Apr 09, 2007 12:50 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 6:31 am

Renee;

Funny thing is I've never been able to fully comprehend the concept of biorhythms or numerology. Those sort of concepts are just a bit too abstract for my image-addicted mind. But wow...interesting results for that test. What was the motivation for starting the biorhythm test in the first place?


It was a statistics class (of some sort); but NOT "general statistics". That was VERY LONG ago, back in the '80s (I'm a crusty old grizzled geezer / military retiree / Signals Intelligence, or "SIGINT". Basically a cryptographer / signals anolysis).

Most of us in the class knew each other (we worked together; were I was stationed, we TENDED to take college classes together because of shift work). AND we each applied the study to some co-workers who were not in the class.

I forget precisely what the task was, but we were broken down into workgroups, and we had to submit a project for approval. We were supposed to do a statistical anolysis of some type applied to group(s) of real people. It could be serious, or it could have been ridiculous; it didn't matter, and as a matter of fact I recall that the instructor said "to have fun with it".

For example, a group might have done a study to see IF there was a correlation between the type of coffee a person drinks, and the occurance of the persons ancestors who's names begin with the letter "D". (hehehe). The point was just to do the study, as long as the study was sound.

The biorhythms thing was my idea. Since childhood, I was always *interested* in astrology, magic, wicca, tarot, etc., but I was also heavily into science. "Healthy scepticism / Open Mindedness". One basic fascination that I think I have is simply "what systems are operating in the background that we DON'T see?". Hence I have always been into math, celestial mechanics, astrophysics, astronomy, etc., science was (is) *PART OF* my way of evaluating "non-mainstream ideas and practices". WITHOUT being judgemental.

While I was in New England (stationed there for 5 years, Fort Devens MA as an instructor) I was ... "closely" ... associated with a few wicca people / groups. They *knew* that I was a "seeker", a person *interested*, but not necessarily a "believer". It was all OK.
:)
User avatar
IsAiah AkA figgy
 
Posts: 3398
Joined: Tue Oct 09, 2007 7:43 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 10:58 am

I think that this thread is a great idea.

( a ) I wonder if astrology / birthsigns might have a greater impact in the next TES game? Or the one after? Etc.

( b ) I wonder if somehow an astrology-based MOD might be made for Oblivion / Morrowind (I still play that). Like the BirthSign, but expanded, and having small influences on almost everything that happens daily.

( c ) Even if mods aren't developed, it would be great if some kind of "astrological system" could be developed for TES. It would have to be different for different TES games, by necessity (as far as I know, there are no CONSISTANT constellations. We could all take screenies of the sky and *make them up*). As far as I know, there are no other planets in TES, just the 2 moons.
User avatar
remi lasisi
 
Posts: 3307
Joined: Sun Jul 02, 2006 2:26 pm

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 5:21 am

No offense, but witchcraft? I think you're crazy. But still interesting.


There is nothing crazy about Witchcraft. At least no more so than any religion or philosophy. http://www.witchvox.com/va/dt_va.html?a=usfl&c=basics&id=2870
User avatar
brian adkins
 
Posts: 3452
Joined: Mon Oct 01, 2007 8:51 am

Post » Sun Oct 04, 2009 3:45 am

I think it's neat how you made an astrolgoy chart for your character, but as a man of science I'm afraid I consider astrology to be complete nonsense. I hope you're not offended, because it's not meant as an offense, it's just me being brutally honest. Also, the link to the horoscope doesn't seem to work for me.

And for the record I wasn't always quite as scientifically inclined as I am today. I was pretty interested in astrology myself back when I was 16 and there was a time when I acctually believed I could see into the future. :D

Note that less than 20 people is a small sample, but you "had to be there". Our surveys were very well designed, we put a lot of thought into it. The results were too strong to be a coincidence.


Unfortunately as far as the reliability of the findings is concerned the size of the sample is important but the strength of the findings (how strongly some people matched the supposed biorythm) doesn't matter at all.

To illustrate my point let's take a look at an entirely different hypothetical experiment. Let's say we want to know if I'm any good at basketball and we devise a test where I throw the ball at the basket from a long distance. And let's say I acctually manage to throw the ball through the hoop in my first attempt. We have a sample of 1 and I have a 100% success rate at shooting from long distance, which is a very strong result. But in reality I'm a horrible basketball player and I just got lucky. If I tried to throw the ball a few more times (increase the sample), chances are I'd miss all the time and my success rate would drop very quickly. So as we can see the size of the sample is relevant to the accuracy of the findings, but the result of the experiment itself tells us nothing about how reliable it is.


I don't have a clue how it works. It's one of those things that exists somehow even though we can't see it. We overrate our brains sometimes; there's alot we can't see or detect in our world.


If we can't see or detect it, how do you know it's there? ;)


One of the mistakes people make with cards (and divination-type astrology) is they think they're "fated" to a certain path. Then they get all freaked out. I believe there are always different paths to choose. Tarot cards merely illuminate some of them.


Correct me if I'm wrong, but the way I understood you, you are basically saying that divination shows only a single possible future (or maybe a narrow set of possible futures) which doesn't have to come true. And to me that sounds awfully like "divination doesn't really tell us much".


If it does exist and has an actual impact, surely the mechanics behind it should be discernible, right?


Yes, ultimately they should, but that doesn't mean they need to be discernable with our current level of scientific knowledge. For example people have been using compasses for centuries before figuring out how electromagnetism works.

If one wished to debunk astrology a properly done statistic anolysis would be a much better way to do it. Have several different astrologists (the more, the better) chart the same group of 10000 or more random people (none of the astrologists should know anything about any of these people other than the exact date and location of birth) and make a control group by having some random guy make wild guesses about what the 10k people are like. And the astrologists should naturally all be among the best in their field. We would want a half-trained rookie screwing up the experiment, would we?

Then compare the results of different astrologists. Results should be compared both on the level of the entire sample and on an individual level. By comparing o nan individual level I mean that for example if the astrologists made different predictions of what a certain person is supposed to be like, that would cast doubt on the validity of astrology even if their overall accuracy was pretty good. Finally compare the accuracy of the astrological predictions on the level of the entire sample with the accuracy of the wild guesses.

Too bad we probably won't ever see this experiment come true so for now we have to satisfy ourselves with little bits like a part from the beginning of http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/page/10/.

Me too. I think I did tarot readings for my characters way back in the day (my D&D characters), too, but that was so long ago. I know me and my brother made rules for arcane arts, though.

I don't consider myself a true witch, but I've definitely am able to do a few limited things which I'm not speaking of publicly! I can send you a PM on that subject! I've always been able to a few limited magics, since I was a kid. But I've never been able to expand on this with actual books, ingredients, items, etc.


If you can actually do any kind of magic, you could try applying for the http://www.randi.org/site/index.php/1m-challenge/challenge-faq.html. Basically the James Randi Educational Foundation is offering $ 1 million to anyone who can show, under proper observing conditions, evidence of any paranormal, supernatural, or occult power or event.

And if you don't have faith in your own abilities (maybe you'd be too nervous to do it right or something) you might want to inform your Wicca friends who have more skill. Maybe they can win the reward. It should be worth a try. A million is a pretty nice sum after all.


Thanks! And thanks to everyone who's posted so far. I didn't know what to expect when I posted this topic last nite, was really nervous about it, actually. I didn't expect everyone to agree or believe in this stuff, and I half-expected to find a bunch of flames when I showed up here today! So I'm glad everyone has been respectful. :thumbsup:


Oh dear. Such lack of faith in the diligence of our ever-vigilant moderators. :nono: ;)

There is nothing crazy about Witchcraft. At least no more so than any religion or philosophy. http://www.witchvox.com/va/dt_va.html?a=usfl&c=basics&id=2870


I fully agree with the sattement that Witchcraft is no more crazy than any other religion. :whistling: ;)
User avatar
Multi Multi
 
Posts: 3382
Joined: Mon Sep 18, 2006 4:07 pm

Next

Return to IV - Oblivion