Piper was gagging for it in my playthrough, I kept resisting the flirt option though, then when we reached the full affinity the option is no longer there, I'm broken

Go with Cait, she knows what she wants and doesn't play games with you

Haven't met Cait yet

You got friendzoned.

Piper is companion now, she walks around everywhere only in underwear and she doesn't mind at all ...

Caits quotes after you rest are.....well....probably the most entertaining of the female companions.

"You may call this a Brewery, but I call it a Church"

-Cait in the Beantown Brewery.

Also, everything you need to know about Cait in one sentence.........

Cait is awesome, she like stealing, killing innocent people, pickpocket, naked, asking for more money, and defend you instead of shooting at you like Piper if you accidentally kill someone.

+1,000,000 for the Cait mate!

I friendzoned piper....that chick is annoying as hell and not is not cute. I have seen plenty of people who thing she is hot but i am afraid those people don't get out much.