» Mon Feb 01, 2010 8:38 am
There are stats available for online play beyond Xfire, Steam regularly releases stats (which approximately ties COD4 and CS:Source) and Games for Windows Live stats are released at least semi-regularly, I was never saying your assumption is wrong, I'm just saying using Xfire as the sole factor for determining for whats popular or not might not be the wisest move, as there are many determining/mitigating factors. Statisics are always tricky.
For example, we can say 'of the people who use Xfire more of them play COD4 than COD2.' What we can't say is the same percentage of COD2/4 players that DON'T use XFire is the same percentage of people who DO use Xfire, and therefore it's safe to assume they are nearly identical. that's not to say they won't be similar in most cases, but the idea is to get a picture of the community, not the picture thats easiest to find and sits easiest with the viewer. Just like with all statistics, if you don't gather all the data possible then it would be hard to determine outliers and anomalies.
Ventrilo is a good example, if they were into the data mining game and was posting stats for what people used vent for, that would be all well and good, but it would also be silly to assume the numbers would apply to teamspeaks use. It would also be silly to assume they would be vastly different, but they would certainly be different due to several factors, probably the foremost being price.
/book