» Fri Feb 18, 2011 9:41 pm
Well, I think we might see some of the same reactions as Oblivion had initially.
When it was first published, it was touted the best RPG ever by reviewers. giving it 9, 10 and once in a while 8. I think there's a good chance that it will happen to Skyrim too. The one thing that might change this is that even though Skyrim will have nice graphics, it won't be as cutting edge as Oblivion was. It might seem svcky now in 2011, but back in 2006 the graphics was superb. This and the sheer scope of the game, I think led a lot of reviewers to close forget the things that svcked with Oblivion, like bad storytelling, lousy fighting and much less customization and roleplaying than in Morrowind. Since the visuals won't be as astounding today, the reviewers might see Skyrim for what it is (hopefully a 9 or 10), and maybe be a little more realistic in their reviews.
The same I think will probably happen with me and other gamers. The first week I played Oblivion, I loved it, but then gradually i realized that it lacked a lot that I had loved in Morrowind. I can mention a lot of detailes, but to say that it lacked Morrowind's grandness will cover my feelings. So while I would have given the game a 9 or maybe even a 10 initially, my second review after a month or so would have been a 6 or seven (8 on a good day). Hopefully this won't happen again. Hopefully Bethesda has learned something by reading reviews and forums on Oblivion, Morrowind and Fallout, and now knows what works and what doesn't.
So I will be optimistic and say that despite my experience with Oblivion, I hope and think Skyrim will be more to my liking and like Morrowind feel fresh and interesting even after 400 hours (Morrowind also became a bit boring after 800 hours, but Oblivion I didn't give more then 400 before I stopped playing) and I hope i even then will give it a 10.