Actually its been confirmed what your carrying. The

I executed a beggar asking for water. Why would I spare someone who actually did wrong by me?

"Deserve has nothing to do with it."

As with all games, I try to keep the kill count to a minimum. I find it a lot more interesting that way.

I'm gonna let him live... sure... He can live all the way up until I find him. Everybody dies, some just die quicker when i have the proper motivation.

I'll probably kill him, but I want to learn why he did it first, it could be very interesting...

It all depends on why the shooter shot me as to how I am going to shoot the shooter.

Only way the punk that shot my character would be allowed to live would be for the game to be "real-world" enough that a large hollowpoint to the knee would make him walk funny the rest of his life, and his knee ache every time the weather changed- thus reminding him constantly of the grievous error he committed by not finishing me when he had the chance.

Since I doubt the damage modeling will allow for that...he dies. Period. Why he shot me is irrelevant- that he shot me is all I need to know.

Well, no matter why he did it, he DID shoot you in the head. He tried to kill you, and might have succeeded if the doctor and his robot friend hadn't helped you. No matter why he did it, it doesn't change the fact that he did it, and that kind of thing isn't something one forgives easily. Ultimately, though, the choice of whether I'll kill him or not (I'd assume we'll be given the option to spare him, anyway.) depends on the sort of character I'm playing, it depends on how nice my character is, I suppose the shooter's motives might also tie into it, after all, one might be more inclined to let him live if he only did it because he was paid, especially if the person who hired him to do it was no longer paying him. Either way, though, I'd want to know his motives simply because I usually like to know why things happen the way they do in stories.

I'll beat him half to death, then my companion will beat him half to death.

But I'll just do the half death beating if hes got a good reason or something to give me.

Nothing personal.. just business

He seems just awesome to me and I love the voice acting already from the few lines we heard him say.. But I'll probably shove the package down his throat while saying: "You wanted this huh? well here, have it!" After that I'll deliver the body containing said package to the guy I'm supposed to give it to. :disguise:

:foodndrink: Cheers to that.

Depends.

If Obs pulled a John Marston as the shooter's motives, I'm going to spare him and hopefully help him save his family. Be one heck of a climix, he and I barge in guns blazing side by side.

However, if he did it for personal reasons that isn't to save a relative/friend, he's dead.

I'm sure he had his reasons, if it's for the "bigger picture" which in the end might turn out to be the best for everyone then I'm gonna let him live.
If it's for selfish and greedy reasons then I'm gonna shoot him.
But if he has an awesome personality then he's going to be my BFF.

It depends on his reasons like why did he shoot the courier, why didn't he want the package to reach its destination.
My character is going to be a mercenary type character where she will go with who ever has the better reward depending on a couple factors so she's probably gonna let Benny live depending on what he offers her.

I dunno, I'm on the fence on whether or not I'm going to let "Matthew Perry" live. If he entertains me like he's my own personal clown in a checkered suit, then perhaps... =p

First off Matthew Perry's a fantastic actor. Everyone who has seen Studio 60 on the sunset street knows that.

Secondly like I said before I don't see any reason to kill him than petty revenge. I like his charachter actually.

I think it depends why he did it, and how many caps I can get out of him for sparing his life... :flamethrower:

well I won′t kill him for shooting me, but if he pulls a gun on me I wont hesitate to shoot first.

So....you're asking whether or not we are going to let someone who has a unique weapon live? I think not in my case, yoink!

Hi matt
Didnt know you posted in this forum!!
Havent seen you much since Friends was on TV.
haha

maybe. depends on how he can repay me for a bullet wound to the cranium.