This is specific to Oblivion, but lore nonetheless I think. Clavicus Vile's quest for you is to require Umbra, and in return he will give you his Masque, but there's the option to keep Umbra. All throughout the quest Barbas urges you not to bring Clavicus the sword, and when you actually get the sword, he tells you just to keep it, because it would be nothing but trouble for Clavicus Vile. If you decide to keep the sword, Barbas tells you that it was nice knowing you, as if the player should fear some retribution.
My questions are as follows:
Is there any (known) history between Clavicus Vile and Umbra, or is it simply implied?
Is there any (known) history between Naenra Waerr and Clavicus Vile?
Was Barbas simply tricking the player, and if so, does he have a (known) history of this?