» Wed Jun 16, 2010 9:24 am
From a previous thread:
Was Uriel a womanizer who proliferated his line with figuratively any woman who crossed his path? Was practically the better part of the Septim line devoted to making ofshoots of the Septim line? Yes and yes. Are there likely men and women out there with Septim blood in their veins? Yes. These things I know.
But it remains that Bethesda built up a strong case with practically a word-of-god statement via the game's plot that they are done with the Septim line. I would be incredibly surprised if they retconned their "he's the last one" ending to continue the Septim line. In terms of the direction of the series as a whole, they seem to be shunting it in the direction of post-Septim life. Think of Oblivion's ending as comparable to their writing http://www.imperial-library.info/mwbooks/notesracial.shtml. Are half-breeds and cross-races possible in the lore? Certainly; we have many examples. But the point of that book is to say, "You're not getting hybrid races, so don't ask for them." So too, I think, with Oblivion's ending. It's meant to say, "The Septim line is finished now, so don't ask for their return." Again, whether that is a good thing or not depends on many things, not the least of which how they will go about displaying a world without the Septims.
However, let's consider some explanatory possibilities Bethesda might use to explain Martins' acceptance as a bastard child and the non-acceptance or non-consideration of the rest of the spread blood of the Septims.
1) The remaining Septims may all be hypothetical bastard-children of differing degrees. And bastard-children don't regularly hold claim to the throne. Martin was a huge and obvious exception, as his becoming Emperor was vital to the continued existence of the Dagon-free world. Post-Oblivion-crisis, the Elder Council's self-serving natures and greediness will undoubtedly return, meaning they won't be so kind to bastard-children.
2) Obviously, at the time of the Oblivion crisis, places where there would have been heirs to the throne were devoid of heirs to the throne. Whether that happened over the course of decades (natural death without offspring) or whether the Dawnmen got to them and their families, too, (expected, since they were planning on removing all heirs, not just the Emperor and sons), they did not exist since the Elder Council would simply have summoned them to the Imperial City and crowned one Emperor, rendering the whole Oblivion plot nonexistent.
3) Even if the Dawnmen missed some legitimate Septim heirs, the mood of the Elder Council may have changed post-Oblivion-crisis; they may be no longer willing to support the Septim line. After all, most of the citizenry of Cyrodiil received the false tale that Martin was the very last heir; if the council denied a claimant rights to the throne with no Amulet of Kings to verify, or they simply disposed of a claimant to remove public scrutiny, the Elder Council could then set up the beginnings of a puppet-Empire, even moreso that what the Septim Empire was at some times.
4) Again, even if the Dawnmen missed some legitimate Septim heirs, perhaps someone with enough charisma or backing simply claimed the throne. It's not like Tiber or Reman didn't do that back in the day. Perhaps a high-ranking official from within the Legion, supported to ascension by his troops, etc, etc. Someone takes over enough territory, leans on the variables enough to make it unwise for the Elder Council to protest, and hijacks the throne. Within a few centuries, people would be speaking of that line with the same legitimacy that they did the Septim line.