I think the biggest reason you are seeing bad reviews because the AI is terrible which makes the single player pretty bad. They are giving it an 8 because the potential that multiplayer has. I think SD really failed with trying to "blur" the lines of SP and MP, should have just made a traditional single player campaign and this probably would have gotten a 9(and some better AI) from a lot more sites.
To be honest, I do not care about single player, never have for an FPS. If I want to care about single player, go play Fallout 3 or Mass Effect. Or any other RPG for that matter. FPS are true multiplayer games, so I will probably love this game since most of the focus seems to be on multiplayer.
True. Also, despite that every one says this is a FPS meant for every one, this is actually a niche game. You need to love multiplayer, objective based gaming. A reviewer isn't going to be in that niche market, so obviously it won't appeal as much.
Check the user reviews versus the site reviews. Much higher. This, my friends, is a cult classic!
At least Gamespot has the goodwill to delay their review until they can fully play it online. Go Gamespot! (unless you insult Brink, in which case go to
bliviongate:)