» Fri May 06, 2011 4:04 pm
Black-Horse Courier "Emperor Promises: Free Magica for all"
The world does seem to imply that Magica is empirical in nature, like Kant's transcendental aesthetic only in the sense of Magica being an inherent form of intuition, an abstract concept like spatiality/temporality. Its vague nature does however result in contradictions; the art is extremely popular, accesible, everyone uses it and does so without any particular difficulty (a kind of logical fallacy, a tear in the logical fabric of the fantasy-world). Oblivion gave us the Ayleids, another potential thread in tracing the history of magic (I suppose it is a world ever-expanding inwards, with every series).
If the occult fascination behind the Psijiici mystery-cult is to be believed, surely it would have occurred in a low-magic world, or one where powerful arcanists were rare? I use Tolkien's example, where the synthesis of some proto-Germanic/Norse polytheism did go just as far as to justify some use of magic - God-given and well-defined through the use of song - but one which wasn't as popular as Lord Jornibret's ditties, or a two-coin play by that hack named Curio. Ultimately, the voyage of a mage in such a world should be something akin to a peripety and anagnorisis, a tormented experience ending in some ultimate self-discovery, whether for good or bad; this is indicated in the Old Method (or Old Way), the True Teachings (if you like) or the semiology behind the Tower (somewhat of a Jungian anology). Perhaps it would have been easier to create a system of Magic as a form of technology (like in Dying Earth), more immediate and simpler than anything else.
In any fantasy-world the use of magic should ideally come from both scientific and non-scientific processes. Such was the use of magic in the Middle Ages, or in the ornately-scripted Middle-Eastern Grimoires: I don't see how it is achieved solely by supplication. The latter a facet of the divine (an aspect which undoubtedly plays a more important part here); however no distinction is made, magic encompasses the many aspects of the same art. Feel free to send me a private message if you've found how to turn metal into gold.
Lastly (no doubt I've committed murder by boredom here, killing off gentle-readers with senseless drivel) there are discrepancies regarding the Great House Telvanni, playing a pivotal role in the arcane arts. Were the Great Houses established before the fall and disappearence of the Psijiic Order? If so then the monastic order's place in history loses context or exclusivity. Did the Telvannis tap into some other unknown source for Magica, or perhaps the methods were different? I don't know whether Galerion was of Elven descent, but it is certain that the imperious and arrogant nature of Dunmer would never have been a part of something readily accessible to all n'wahs , to use "nature" synecdochially. Chew on these things and feel free to spout them out again, due to their foul taste.