Nope, the OP is asking if people would pay for something that's free, if it included "extras" (which really
aren't) that are also already available free- like unpacked versions of the game data files any owner of the game already has, which they could unpack themselves, or a manual which would be nothing more than a hardcopy of some of the free tutorials on the web.
For future reference,
comprehend the OP before posting, thanks.
And how did I say anything against that?
The OP does not say that the Creation Kit should not be available free, something Ryo no Reiji apparently thought:
IT should be as Free as always has been!
Stop Trying to charge for stuff people , Bad enogh are DLC paying 5 bucks for stuff that should be free, now you want me to pay to mod!
Read the quoted post before posting, thanks.
EDIT: Oh, and "or a manual which would be nothing more than a hardcopy of some of the free tutorials on the web." - this could be used as argument for the Collectors Edition object that everyone is so fond of, the map of the world. It's just a hardcopy of something you can find on the web. So, imo, that is a bad argument to use.