Now then, here's the deal. I completed the quest "How Little We Know" and went with the "evil" option accidentally, as I turned Cachino over to Big Sal since he seemed like the shady character. It wasn't until I followed through the other events and completed the quest that I realized I gave the Omertas the go-ahead to kill everyone on the strip. So I reloaded the oldest save I had, right after I completed Troike's and Canden's requests, but before telling Big Sal and officially ending the mission.
So here I am, trying to do resetquest and trying to reset the character, but because the button man kills Cachino in the office, no matter how many times I try to kill/resurrect or disable/enable, at BEST he's just a model that stands there and won't talk or move. Also, the receptionist doesn't have the dialog option of asking about Cachino (like she does when you're first looking for him.)
For any of you suggesting I set the quest to complete, that storyline makes Cachino vital down the road, and will only bug my game worse.
This is seriously the worst. I've always at least had an inkling of how to avoid evil, this quest was written HORRIBLY, I've got 40 hours put into this game and I can't move an inch without getting Cachino working. Someone PLEASE help me!