You know, one motivation behind a preference for the "aboriginal beast race" origin for orcs may be yet another facet of a reaction against the Ehlnofeycentric interpretation of the lore. There may well be more texts to tear apart where Orsimer are concerned; however, for some, I imagine the notion that Ocrs are "yet another kind of elf" is an unsatisfying conclusion. As it stands, the only races which do not somehow tie into the Elhnofey line is maybe the Argonians, and perhaps the Tsaeci.
This is understandable, to me. While the main story about the creation of Nirn concerns the activities of Lorkhan and what became the Aedra, there are also hints that Nirn may have been cobbled together from the remnants of nine worlds that came before, with the largest chunks being those of the Ehlnofey and the Hist. What else came from these other worlds? Some of us seize on the "undocumented" races in the hopes of finding traces of yet another of the lost worlds... and react violently to anything tying these undocumented races to the Ehlnofey. Witness the reaction when I suggest that the Riecklings may truly be what are left of the Falmer...
RIEKLINGS CANNOT BE FALMER!!!!1 THEY ARE NOT THE
SAME!!!!11
:rolleyes:
But seriously: What about the Imga? They do not fit in either, unless they are yet another kind of elf changed by Azura.
If I'm not completly mistaken there's also a (now extinct) race of aboriginal birdmen, that lived in the Cyrodiil area before other settled there.
Going to TIL now to check it out.
edit: Oh, and before I go, I
know that I have been one of the most valiant and steadfast Riekling-not-Falmer-knights before, but I'm really only anti the idea that falmer always have been rieklings, because that is ridiculous. While I find the idea that the rieklings are "descendants" of Falmer quite farcical as well, I haven't really got any proof against it, so I must accept the possibility.
edit 2: I found the mention of birdmen - it's in http://www.imperial-library.info/obbooks/father_niben.shtml:
Brilliant flightful creatures of glorious colors
Greeted them in Aldmeri language,
Making the mer wonder, until they
Understood they were only calling back
The word they were speaking without
Understanding it, and then the sailors
Laughed.
Topal the Pilot was enchanted with the islands
And the feathered men who lived there.
There the Niben stayed for a moon, and the bird
Men learned how to speak their own words,
And with taloned feet, to write.
And then these notes:
We know that this strange, friendly feathered people the Pilot encounters will be lost - in fact, this poem is the only one where mention is made of the bird creatures of Cyrodiil. The literacy that Topal gives them is evidently not enough to save them from their eventual fate, likely at the hands of the "cat demons," who we may assume are ancient Khajiiti.