I even created a new account with another email, and right off the bat, login doesn't work there either... Tried password reset, and received no email from the site.
The site actually says that it was "successfully sent" as well.
I hope someone can resolve it, I can't even find any contact info on this site. If this is any indication of what's to come with the retail game, this is a serious problem... Especially when the customer is being asked to spend $59.99 for a PC title.