Hm. I don't know. FONV has got the story going for it and the companions, but it's so so glitchy. I don't think the glitches will factor in though. I've only played Halo: Reach, which I love. And watched my daughter play Red Dead Redemption, which is a beautiful fun looking game. Neither game has many glitches, just a handful maybe, and both have good stories. I'm still upset about Jorge. I tried playing ME2, but I just can't get into it for some reason. So I don't know about that one. And I don't know about any other candidates.
When I think of "Game of the Year", I think of an all around fun game.
Do you think that the bugs and issue will be a major gripe in the chances of it being released as a game of the year edition?
I don't think so. I think it will be other aspects of the game that prevent it from being released as a goty.