So I'm trying to get the White Glove to convert to Cannibalism, the problem is theres no option for it when talking to Mortimer. All he tells me is that I don't have the stomach for his work.

So, I read theres a way to work for him right from the get-go after talking to Marjorie. I don't believe there was ever an option or speech challenge to help him, only the option of asking for work.

Heres what I did:
1. Talked to Marjorie and exhausted all dialogue options.
2. Talked to Mortimer and exhausted all dialogue options.
3. Quest updated telling me to tell Caesar I failed (Wtf?)
4. Started Beyond the Beef by talking to Heck.
5. Exhausted all dialogue about the inspector from both of them.
6. (Saved before entering kitchen area)
7. Made it to Phillipe and killed him.
8. Took Phillipes recipes.
9. No clue what I was supposed to do from here? I had no quest markers so this was all free form trying to figure this out.
10. I reloaded and talked to Phillipe and said I would help him. This seemed to be a dead end as well...

Also, there is no way my Berserker is good or even near good, my last save had an evil title. What do I need to accomplish in order for him to agree to help me (Besides cannibal perk)

So thats everything, I have no clue what to do. There is no way I'm restarting my Berserker again because I screwed up this quest... Help would be appreciated.

Probably a bug, I don't think those quests have any relation.

You have to do the quests for the White Gloves before that part, and I think you have to sabotage Mortimer's feast by changing the recipe for the quests.

I'm not 100% if you need to actually make them convert. I have a theory. If you get rid of Mortimer and expose him as a cannibal, could you swing your newfound influence to convince Marjorie to join? Or do you need to be cannibals?