» Thu Sep 08, 2011 11:49 am
Just got to comment again on a trend I've noticed throughout this thread:
A lot of folks seem to consider a mage 'impure' if he has a weapon on him, or if it's not a certain type of weapon (dagger, staff, or shortsword). I must disagree with this assessment for several reasons.
Wizards, witches, mages, sorcerors, all throughout fiction have handled just about every weapon a 'warrior' character has. It's not whether or not you use a weapon at all that defines the difference between a wizard and a warrior, it's your level of proficiency. Any child could pick up an axe or blade and have a basic, rudimentary understanding of it's use, whereas a seasoned warrior will see the weapon as simply an extension of themselves. Regardless of whether a mage utilises a polearm, longsword, axe, or flail, they'll have at least enough common knowledge to crack a few mudcrab shells. Will they be the equal of a warrior in skill? No. That's what the difference between an armed mage and a battlemage is.
Furthermore, as another already commented, it's a dangerous world the TES characters live in. There are many, many ways to neutralise magic, and anyone with a smidgeon of intelligence would have some form of backup.
As for Conjuration magic 'blurring the lines' between a pure mage and a warrior, I disagree. Just as a warrior works hard and trains daily to know his weapon, he also comes to know his armour; eventually even the heaviest, bulkiest cuirass would become like a second skin. A conjurer achieves the same effect, only through magic. He doesn't actually know how to move around in armour, but the armour he conjures essentially is weightless, and no burden on him. More than that, unlike a warrior, your armour has a time limit, forcing you to take a slightly more offensive role in a conflict so that the battle can be resolved before you armour fades. In the end, claiming that conjuring weapons and armour simply makes you another warrior is like saying using Alteration magic to unlock doors and chests makes you just another thief.