You could just make an illusion spell.
If it were to be illusion, it would have to be purely a sensory change. Physical changes go outside of the domain. I thought it could make an interesting basis for an artifact. Seems like the type of thing, as either an artifact of illusory or physical change, which could lead to a fun story.
Still not sure which would be the best way to go.
An example of how a story could go (grimdark flavored): The mirror falling into the possession of a lord's house, the lord giving the mirror to his daughter as a gift, the daughter learning of the abilities and using them. She expires the last charge of the mirror, is found by the guards and taken as someone involved in the abduction of the now-missing daughter of the lord, and is executed. The lord tears his entire kingdom apart looking for his missing daughter, only to eventually learn the truth of the mirror by some means and then going mad with guilt. Possibly killing himself.