even with brightness all the way down I can still see plenty, caves and dungeons do require some light tho for details if your treasure hunting.
I don't want it to be pitch black but currently the settings seem a bit too high on default, just my opinion tho. Even with all the way down I can see just bout everything.
True, I do remember oblivion being way to bright, unrealistically so.
Perhaps I have my TV settings pretty dim as well(in fact I know I do, the sun is my nemesis). So the combination provides a decent setting for myself.
I do remember I realistic mod for Oblivion that removed all none light source light. There you needed a torch to see anything. That combined with the drop torch mod made for some good times. I'm not fond with mechanics of the dual wielding equipping system. Can you currently hit say "1" to bring up a torch and then hit it again to go back to your previous weapon? Then I could see myself using it in certain dark areas to look for loot after dispatching any baddies from the shadows. Currently there is not enough quickslot items and I can't justify using one up for a torch at the moment.