» Tue Oct 06, 2009 12:01 pm
It's not so much a choice between MW's dark and moody feel and OB's bright and cheerful one; I'd prefer a lot more CONTRAST. There should be beautiful, serene valleys, with waves of bright flowers turned toward the sun, and dark, sinister forests where you can't see more than a few dozen yards for the foliage and shadow. There should be quaint and pleasant villages and dirty and depressing ones. OB lacked VARIETY, more than anything else. The levelling and scaling just added to that lack of variety, by restricting what you could find wandering in that cheerily bland landscape. After a few hours of play, it all felt the same; it was all I could manage just to suffer through it and finish the MQ, just so I could argue the point from an "informed" perspective. After that, I never felt any urge to go back and try all of the various side quests and explore the rest of the map, so I've apparently not seen some of the game's "good" parts.
The stark contrasts in MW between the swamps of the Bitter Coast and the rocky highlands of the West Gash, or between the lush, green fields of the Ascadian Isles and the ash wastes of Molag Amur, made exploration and travel worthwhile, and a joy. In a matter of a few minutes walking, you could go from "beauty" to "horror", and back again. My first foray inside the Ghostfence, I felt the depressing weight of hopelessness descending, and nearly turned back on the spot.
In OB, it felt too much like "more of the same old", no matter where you went, aside from the more mountainous northern regions, which at least were refreshingly different from the rest of it. The thick jungles of the south were just closer packed forest, and didn't feel markedly different from the rest of the map; more like a minor local variation. Even the plane of Oblivion quickly lost any intimidation value, because it was so heavily overdone with gore to the point of bordering on humor, and the bright and shiny look to it just made a mockery of the whole thing once you got past the initial shock.
Neither poll choice fits: I want BOTH.