Been a staunch supporter of KB+M combination since I could first get on a PC, but I do have consoles and I know how effective it can be. So, my question is for those who are actually use a Xbox controller on the PC is how well its implimented and what kind of gaming experience your having. Im considering using one.

I tried playing an fps with a controller once and its awful. The acceleration, the sloweness, the lack of accuracy, etc

Keyboard and mouse I'd say. Only problems I see are the terrible ui and the vertical acceleration that I cant get rid of. You also have hotkeys with keyboard and mouse.

I love the 360 controller with the PC.

I highly recomend going with the Xbox 360 controller for both Skyrim and The Witcher 2 on PC. Both games give a far more enjoyable experience with the controller. Stick with Keyboard + Mouse for FPS Games.

I couldn't even fathom playing this game on a controller.

I suggest trying it out for a while. If you don't like, you can always switch back.

I don't like KB+M. It's too uncomfortable. /:
Controllers ftw!