*Shrug* I didn't think the Al'kir were Assassins at all.

An Assassin hell-bent on fulfilling his contract wouldn't be turned away at the gate of Whiterun..

I don't know, man. I don't think anyone with good intentions will walk up to each and every Redguard woman they see and be like, "[WOMAN], you're coming with us!"

I killed the guards and the woman for no reward whatsoever.

I only did it cause it was fun, and their corpses lie in a stream near the Whiterun gates.

Wow. Someone was paying attention. I didn't pick up on that until after I turned her in.

You would be if you walked in through the front door screaming, "Yo bishes, I'm here for so-and-so get out ma way!!!" and had the Reach's guards to contend with. Which is exactly what the two Al'kir assassins did. Waltzed in the front door demanding the Reach turn her over. Yeah, good luck with that you arrogant idiots. My sword, and the swords of my buddies might have something to say about that.

For me this was probably the hardest choice in the game, so far.

In the end I handed her over because I believed the guards. But I never did feel 100% right about it. Often felt that I should have just left the quest incomplete.

im thinking that the alikr are the good guys they sound more like it, and they actually pay you and dont try to kill you after youve helped them(which if they were assassins probably wont happen and they will try to kill you after youve helped) they only capture saadia, and when u take her to them she doesnt really sound innocent xD also redguards probably wont work for the thalmor after they conquered them..

I sided with her because all men lie! :angel: