» Wed Dec 14, 2011 10:40 pm
Basically, Morrowind was a true RPG in that anything you did relied on your character's abilities, not you as the player. That's what "role play" is (unless you are role playing yourself, but you would not level up to 100 strength, intelligence, etc either in such a case).
After Morrowind, Beth decided to go the "action" game route rather than stick with actual role playing games. Frankly, they listened to a vocal minority, but anyway... that's what they did. Their games are still great games, but not great role playing games. Role play requires imagination - ask any actor, for example.
Skyrim has Morrowind's darker atmosphere, but continues down the action path rather than role playing. So... as a fantasy action game with minimal role playing elements, it is excellent. As a role playing game... not so much so.