» Tue Jan 26, 2010 3:38 pm
It's amazing how many threads about this quest have been created since the game was released. Funnily enough, it is one of the quests where Bethesda decided to hide the quest marker, so you'd have to actually think in order to solve the puzzle. Are people just that dumb or the quest is flawed?
I think the quest is somehow flawed. Yes, the piece of evidence is there, but it is very subtle. It turns up when you interrogate Chanel and she describes her actions in the night of the theft. Most people don't actually pay attention to the fact that she said she "spent some time in the courtyard of the castle taking star readings. Then she made her way to the dining area off of the Great Hall. Finally, she went to her quarters to sleep."
When I played that quest, I got focused on the "star readings" part (which obviously contradicts the information that it was raining that specific night) and forgot about the "dining area" part.