So, what do you think? First of all, this thread seems like it could be flame war potential. One of my threads got locked last night because a small handful of posters couldn't keep their egos in check. Please keep it civil if this will be a discussion. Alright, so, actually, it seems to me that as far as guilds are concerned, Skyrim's are better done, like the DB for one.

Skyrim's guild have better stories, less white knight/breaking lore by making necromancers all evil for no reason type stuff, but skyrim's guilds are undermined by thier increadibly short length, giving the player little time to soak in the stories.