» Sun May 05, 2013 3:33 pm
Your certainty that the icon was working correctly, followed by a vague description of the problem, just had me picturing a normal icon.
Your second description of the icon actually makes sense though, as you better explained how the enchanted swirl itself has a black square on it.
Anyways, glad you got it sorted out.
I learned to make icons from http://members.shaw.ca/gdicanada/Downloads/IconMadness.pdf. In case you haven't seen this one, it's helpful in ensuring you don't miss any steps.