I think that we should be able to do power attacks when at low stamina, but at reduced damage.
I voted for option three, and I can imagine the smashed controllers and Mice and Keyboards if Melee was gimped like Magic in Skyrim
I think they should have made all Magic and Mundane attacks require a set amount of Magicka or Stamina. A Power Attack would be like Dual Casting.
I agree with this. I don't think people would be complaining as much about magic if melee fighters had to manage their stamina.
Stamina management for melee has been done by a lot of mods, and I couldn't play without them. Definetly something the vanilla game is lacking.