You see, we're humans.. we don't know what we want
that's why we have forum polls to have other people decide for us
Dead is Dead makes people happy, it puts them on their toes and gives them a challenge; defying it kind of just ruins the whole point on why it puts you on your toes.
michael is in the contradicting planes of oblivion where he doesn't know if we values the character itself more, or the whole point of the character.