I don't think a guild should be created for the sole purpose of having an option for players who aren't interested in it. If there were a lore established reason to create one beyond the scope of just being opposed to the dark brotherhood for the sake of a dichotomy then sure.
For example maybe the hypothetical guild could have quests that send you to protect high value assassination targets? but really who even likes escort quests?? Maybe you could 'purify' (assassinate) members of the dark brotherhood in the name of some other deity lol!
But just for the sake of having opposition? Not in my opinion