Seems I am having a different issue.. I slayed everyone, as I decided to slay the doctor for Danny boy. WHen I get back to Covenant, I slay them all there, too. As everyone else has said, everything is still marked as "steal" and having same problem with turrets. However, my issue lies with the first settler that arrives after I place a beacon for recruitment.. It turns hostile and attacks me. I kill it, and then my follower * Paladin Dance* starts shooting me.. It seems if I do not side with the doctor, I cannot make Covenant a Settlement.. Anyone else having this problem? I tried shooting the cat and that lemonade peddler, too, because it seems I get caught stealing by the cat.. Yes, the cat in the shop caught me stealing. Perhaps that is what triggered the aggressive first settler?. And that's just murder- my companion attacks me yet again. I want this settlement! It's got freakin concrete walls!! Someplace I can actually call my own home!