» Fri May 28, 2010 7:38 am
Over 9000
But seriously, I think OB was a huge success for Bethesda, and MW was a cult classic, I remember DF being more widespread but maybe that's cuz I was in high school and every nerd I knew was playing it like a drug when it first came out...
Fallout rode mostly on OB's success, basically being OB with guns, not Fallout's fanbase, since FO was also a cult classic and the FO fans for the most part were not down with the updating done to their beloved isometric rpg.
I think OB and FO are inextricably linked in that way since the gameplay is so similar. I just hope they don't introduce the combat system from FO back into OB, that needs to stay firmly planted in the future...
When I personally think of RPG franchises, none stick out to me more than TES, even though things like FF and such are far more popular, I personally could care less what Square is doing because those games...um...blow imho (don't hurt me!).
As far as western RPGs, unless its an MMO or something recent like DA, nothing in my mind has really held its own like TES for such a long time. Baldur's Gate has fallen by the way side, and things like Mass Effect and Dragon Age are too young to have the history that TES has.
This doesn't really answer the question, but I think, Oblivion at least is firmly planted in the main-stream of gaming and it will only get bigger from here on out, and any TES sequel will also bring with it the players who 'discovered' Bethesda with FO3.
HOWEVER: Being a movie-person I am firm in the idea that making a TES movie would be similar to making a Dungeons and Dragons movie (anyone catch that amazing piece of cinematic history? <_< ). The problem, narrative wise, is the main character in the game is you, and the games take hundreds of hours to fully complete and explore. So in order to compensate for that they will have to make it about a group of characters who sort of fall into vaguely the most popular choices for players in the game, and then create some generic problem they have to solve. That or they'd have to have the whole film be from the main character's POV. So what I'm saying is it would be a ridiculous fiasco and terrible and simply wouldn't work. In fact, any game where the main character is customizable, ESPECIALLY in name, destroys the ability to create a cohesive narrative that will appease fans and draw in newcomers. Why name? Because you need a hero (Shepherd, Link, Lara Croft, Sam Fisher), and my hero's name is always Reymas the Ashborne. I bet you that isn't anyone else's, is it? So you hear about the TES movie being about the Dunmer orphan Reymas of Ashborne, who was the only survivor of a shipwreck on a remote island as a newborn (literally born during the storm that crashed the ship) and raised by an imperial-separated tribe of sea elves who are eventually massacred by what seems to be some warlock and his band of pirates who show up looking for Reymas as he is the last line of some crazy lineage, he manages to steal a lifeboat and miraculously makes it to Cyrodiil where he is mistaken for another prisoner and thrown in the prison where he wakes up to meet the emporer barging into his cell etc etc etc...that isn't how you imagined it, is it? So you're gonna be disappointed. Hence, no TES movie...ever.