That was romance? Because what we have here is sooooo much better than the Amulet of Mara, oh well. I romanced Piper first, I tried to do it with first Cait but failed the speech check, I had spent the most time with Cait and done all her quests and heard her backstory but at the time my charisma was too low. Just thought I'd try with Piper one day and low and behold it worked, yay. But I did eventually romance Cait once I realized how shallow the whole thing is.