well they DO look like the creature from the black lagoon, just wiki it.
Obviously mirelurks are there to fufill the "Its-a-guy-in-a-suit" aesthetic of some of the monsters.
No....not really.
The Creature from the Black Lagoon really looks like a Zora or something....or just your stereotypical fish man. The Mirelurks, well they're crab people. There's a huge difference between the Mirelurks and the creature, and that difference is: Mirelurks are crabs with bodies, the Creature is a man with fins on his head.
If you ask me, the think that looks the most like Mirelurks are Crab People from South Park, even though the Crab people are more lobster-like than crab-like.