I didn't mind Reputation because it made sense (sort of) ---- you wipe out the Powder Gangers, they hate you and the NCR thinks you're okay. You start shooting the NCR and they think, hey, this gal's a little nuts, better watch her.... then you KEEP killing NCR and they say, Alright, that's enough - put her down! But Caesar is, like.... well, he's like "A ~woman~ did that? Inconceivable!" Then I stab him in the neck and whisper, "I do not think that word means what you think it does"... ;D
Where was I? Oh, yeh, but ~karma~ always struck me as a bit weird ---- if I steal from a raider, I'm a bad person? And who saw me steal?
That's one problem with reputation, too, though ---- if you wipe out an entire Powder Ganger base, who ~knows~ you did that? How can they be mad at you if no one knows what you did? It's that omniscient / omnipresent ~metagame~ feature I don't like. Now, if you do a QUEST for a faction, I can see where that faction might spread the word that you're a good person and their enemies may also hear about your deeds ~against~ them.... but just random stuff no one sees? Shouldn't matter.