So, original game - simple, but fun. Built up my vault, bought a bunch of lunchboxes when they were on sale, got some good stuff, and continued getting upgrades on a semi-regular basis, with legendary items coming once every few days when I had a full crew exploring the wasteland.
First update hits, and the legendaries vanish entirely. With 100+ dwellers going into the wastes daily for several months, all max stat and well-equipped, I've gotten zero legendaries. In several months. With the average round-trip exploration taking six or seven days, we'll say that's four trips per dweller per month. Call it 800-1000 trips. Probably 70-100 items per trip. 50,000-100,000 items. ZERO legendaries. I even had several dwellers that I kept ressing until they were in the wastes for over ten days waste-time, hoping if they found a good weapon they'd drop their current one. Nothing. Just about every person in my vault is using a 17-18 plasma rifle now.
So, for the last few weeks, I haven't bothered to play, because, well, boring, monotonous, no possibility of upgrades. The first update pretty much killed any enjoyment I was having, but I kept trucking until there was obviously no point. Saw there was a new update today.
Wow, this update did more damage than the last one. Impressive.
I have 125 people standing outside of my vault waiting for me to sell the absolute junk each one has to let the next one in. And only ten of them can now go into the wastes to once again not find anything interesting. Suuuuper.
Meanwhile, we have a new survival mode! Where none of my lunchbox purchases carry over, and where I'll absolutely, positively never see any legendary items.
What the game should add:
1) Convenience features for selling junk.
2) Better waste explorer management, to be able to easily see if someone found good items.
3) A return of legendaries.
What the game adds:
1) Item drop nerfs.
2) Waste explorer limit nerfs.
3) More deadly creatures to force you to try to get better gear from lunchboxes, since the legendary drops have been, you guessed it, nerfed.
So, yeah, way to absolutely drive a game into the ground. In four months and two major updates, there's been nothing positive added as far as I'm concerned (I still don't have any Mr. Handy's since I wasn't going to buy more lunchboxes when the game was getting less enjoyable and less rewarding), and plenty of negatives added each update.
So, I hear Fallout 4 is coming soon. This was supposed to get me hyped for it, right? Way to go. I have a hell of a lot less enthusiasm for anything Fallout-related now than I did before Shelter was released.
Bravo.