» Mon Sep 13, 2010 3:47 pm
There have been a few items which look positive, and a few others that appear negative. Overall, I'm expecting a "mixed bag" of "improvements" and "what were they thinking?" moments.
I'm strongly in the "character skills" over "player skill" traditional RPG fan category, although I can see the merits of mixing in action elements as long as it doesn't trivialize the character's role in shaping the experience. While I though that MW was by far the better game, OB definitely had its bright points that fixed a few of MW's problems. The bad side was that it took a number of other problem elements and effectively removed them from the game or made them irrelevant, instead of reworking them. Less < More.
The remark about fewer respawning locations is a potential positive (I thought that the automatic 3 day respawn of almost everything in OB was actually worse than the problem with no respawns in MW), if handled decently. A few things have bad connotations on the face of it, but might still be an improvement, depending on how they're handled (removal of attributes, cutting of still more skills, heavier reliance on perks), while other things that just scare me (unified armor) aren't confirmed.
At the moment, I'm not intending to buy it immediately upon release, but to wait a few days or weeks for a general consensus of opinion about the changes. If it turns out to be an even more FPS-ish action game than OB, then I'll pass on it, or at least wait a year or two until modders have fixed the major flaws and turned it into something worth playing more than just once to "beat the game" (assuming that the CS is released and that the revised engine isn't hardcoded to insure a uniform level of mediocrity), or it hits the "budget bin" and I can buy it for what it's worth. I'm hopeful, but expecting something "about the same as last time", which I consider to have been "good, but not great". Meanwhile, I'm STILL playing MW (modded, because it DID have its fair share of flaws) with some regularity after all this time, long after OB has been relegated to that bottom drawer of "maybe I'll get back to it someday" titles. Hopefully, Skyrim won't join it.