Maybe it is the case that threads which post up somebody's favorite "recommended", "essential" etc. mod list are a detraction.
Yes this is a mods board but, such threads are just like those "introduction" threads, in my mind. At least the unwanted "introduction" threads are relegated by the board moderators to a separate board and are ONLY allowed there. We can be thankful for that.
Every single person who comes to this board can be expected to have a mod load order of their own, just like each of us has a name/board identity. kso shall we all flood the board with copy-pastes and reviews of our mod load? Mercifully, most of us know not to do that.
But you see... what we lack here... is a board to do precisely what you have suggested not be allowed.
As this is the mod board, this would be the PLACE for someone to put their list of recommended mods, whatever they choose to call them, for others to see. There is no other, more 'suitable' board for this, and I think it is laughable that anyone would actually come INTO this thread in order to make comments SOLELY based upon their feeling that it should not be allowed to exist.
Obviously, as it was not deleted and has been allowed to stand for this long... nor is it -alone- in its existence of 'recommended mods' lists posted here... your point was a moot one.
Impotent rage, etcetera, etcetera.
The fact remains that these lists are NOT against the rules.
And for many, these lists are the FIRST time many of these mods are ever seen. Certain folks are even -appreciative- of individuals taking their time to direct them towards what they consider to be 'must have' mods... because otherwise, they might never find them at all.
It's folks who come here, don't like what they read about, and feel the need to devolve and/or hijack the topic completely that bother me.
It's offensive to the author of the thread... it's a hindrance to anyone who might actually WANT to check out the mods... and its' a complete waste of time and effort which might be better spent elsewhere.
Tarrant... you're a damn fine modder... but I had -never- heard of Phalanx until someone posted it up on a list.
If I hadn't seen that list, idly one day... I'd have never developed the love/hate relationship I have with your mod. To begrudge the listing of favorite mods, recommendations, and adoration... for the purpose of what? Cluttering up your board of needy, demanding requests from people who joined TODAY... that's what's eating away at you?
I think you're just taking it a bit too seriously.
They're never going to go away. At best, they might get their own 'sub-forum' or something.