Both FO3 and NV have their place. I agree that in some respects FO3 is better than NV, and in others NV is the victor. When FO3 came out, it was something new and interesting, and though the main story was very bland and horribly scripted, the game had a lot to do. There was a lot to explore(this is not a comparison on map size so much as the magnitude of the game compared to others at the time.) But now with NV, people expect to have a lot of places to discover and are undoubtedly having fun finding them, but beyond getting a new place to fast travel to, a lot of them offer nothing but a couple of caps, or a usually average weapon for the effort of having to find a path because you can't just go over that mountain you were having no problem trekking up just a minute ago because there's now a wall there. New Vegas offers you a much more flexible play style with more options on how you want the story to go, and it certainly has replay value, but I don't see myself wanting to keep running off and find all the dull places again and again. I'd probably rush through the story mode to unlock the different endings as quick as possible, but I'm still enjoying my playthrough so far before doing anything to complete it.
I have to disagree, I find the exploring much more fun in New Vegas for one simple fact, NO METRO TUNNELS!!! Its the wasteland, you can't expect there to still be a ton of stuff lying around just for someone special like you do you? Come on now most stuff is picked clean.
I think FO3 tried to add a more personal, though poorly written, touch to the story. You were looking for your father(and who doesn't like Liam Neeson's voice anyway?), so it gave you more reason to continue. But in NV, you're just out for revenge, plain and simple. Where's the option for people like me, who just wants to find Benny, put a bullet in his head, and get on with my life? Who says I want to get involved in this huuuuuuge political debacle called the Mojave. I'm a human being, my needs and wants are simple. And if I'm wronged, then I'm going to go and get me some revenge and get on with my life, not join the army to better the world cuz I plugged a guy.
The ONLY thing keeping me going in Fallout 3 was revenge too (no not for my fathers death) that had to be continued from my small village Arroyo back in Fallout 2. I will never forgive the Enclave for that!
Okay so let me get this straight, you DIDN'T want to find Benny? You DIDN'T want to get pulled into a very interesting political battle/war? then why buy the game? Don't you know the nature of RPGs? I just don't understand your statement, you get pulled into all of this because of your job, you get caught up in the mess of things. It almost wasn't your character if i remember right but the other guy passed up the Job