LOL
I think personally, some places would become quite polarized on this issue. One would be there is no God, full stop. And the other would be there is a God, full stop.
Also, I don't think that makes you Agnostic. Unless you believe there's a possibility of there being a God like in the Bible or Koran, or whatever, you'd still fall under Atheism.
I'd like for Asatru to be the true religion
Imagine when you die, and you come to wherever you go to when you die, and you find out what religion was actually true. Christians, jews, muslims et cetera would be so confused when they end up in Valhalla or Helheim
or they are reborn as something better/lesser a la hinduism (probably lesser since they didn't believe in the right gods) sitting there as a cockroach and thinking "what did I do wrong?". Or there is just an empty, black void where the only thing that exists is your thought, but it doesn't matter anyways because you don't time perception or memory at all (kind of like remembering a hard night of drinking, but it's constant and forever. Hehehehe.)
Mostly I'm just interested in asatru because everything in it is more awesome, and the stories are so implausible, but if people can believe in the religions that are big today, why can people deem asatru as being silly and improbable? If anything, asatru has more humour (Loki for example)