Skyrim will be legendary. It will forever be remembered through the annals of time as the greatest of all time.
Hopefully you're kidding, or at least trolling. Definitely nowhere to go but down with comments like this.. hopefully you're right, likely you're not.
Games that let me down:
Oblivion - was a big downer for me. Don't get me wrong I had fun playing it, but it was over-hyped. It over-promised and under-delivered. It wasn't what I had hoped it would be.
Red Dead Redemption - so many boring, meaningless quests. Roundup these horses, Ride this carriage and shoot the followers, stop this robbery, etc. I stopped caring about a lot of it. There didn't for me seem to be any connection to the story or characters..
MGS4 - I've played MG since it's inception and every iteration becomes more cutscene-laden, with over-the-top characters. Guess it's just no longer for me.
Call of Duty Series - single player is always fun but too short and a little too much on arcade rails. Multiplayer is full of 12 year old 1337 haxorz kiddiez. woot.
Games that met the hype:
Fallout 3 - was a big step up for Bethesda in their evolution of open world games IMO. Loved it. Hopefully BGS can carry forward that momentum into Skyrim.
Uncharted Series - lived up to the hype and then some.
Bioshock Series - unique art direction, solid gameplay, intense story, and did I mention Bid Daddies?
Ico & Shadow of the Colossus - well there was no hype so how could they go wrong. At the same time how could they possibly have done any better? The Last Guardian anyone?