I recently started a new character, and didn't save since I was level 11 (I'm now 13.) And I got caught stealing and trespassing in Cheydinhal during the quest "Fines" I paid the gold, but ever since random guards (certain ones would, while others would not.) would run twoard me and say I still have a bounty... I'm not sure why it's happening, but now I have to either take off RGO or, reload my lvl 11..

I cannot offer enough support for this issue, but to aid others who might a LO might be helpful.
Also - as I have experianced oddities myself mildly similar - reloading 2 levels back is not too bad.

What's an LO? Thanks for your input, I'll probably just reload.

LO is your Load Order.
Read about it http://sites.google.com/site/oblivionpoinfo/. read the main page then find the LO page, it explains a little about it. The LO page is essentially a wall of text, so skim through, but be sure to understand what it is.

Next; use either OBMM or Wrye to export your LO. Open OBMM (for this example) and select the button that says "Import/Export" and select "Export Load Order". Copy and paste it into (open bracket) spoiler (close bracket) _your LO goes here_ (open bracket) /spoiler (close bracket)

[spoiler]like this[spoiler]

and the result should
.
In Wrye...well you should be using that program, but I myself hardly use it, so I can't remember off the top of my head how to export your LO from there, but it is HIGHLY recommended you do it from Wrye. But I don't feel like opening Wrye right now as I am sure someone will come a lot and basically boot all the information out and give you an education on this stuff that is worthy of being a college major.

I run on vista, and have recently had problems using OBMM, I might download it again soon and retry.