Here are the stats each gun has feel free to comment about them or use them in your argument!
SCAR-H
Damage:
0-35M: 30 Damage
35-infinite: 25 Damage
Rate of Fire: 700RPM
Special Feature:
Single shot increases the damage of the Scar.
0-35M with single shot: 40 Damage
35-Infinite with single shot: 30 Damage
Rate of Fire with single shot: 500RPM
Scarab
Damage:
0-35M: 24 Damage
35-Infinite: 20 Damage
Rate of Fire:900RPM
Special Feature:
Single shot increases the damage of the Scarab
Damage:
0-35M with single shot: 30 Damage
35-Infinite with single shot: 24 Damage
Rate of Fire with single shot: 900RPM
Heres the original post i found theses stats from by CrayHD
http://www.gamesas.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=14357
I personalty am leaning towards the SCARAB for its light-weight and silencer attachment. I also like it because of its higher fire-rate making it more of a sub-machine gun. However, I do like the SCAR's look and enjoy being able to use many under-barrel attachments.