» Tue May 17, 2011 2:40 am
Mehrunes Razor was a very fun dungeon crawl. The reward at the end was meh. I only used it a few times, then put it away in a chest because I can make a better weapon at the enchanting altar, or from the other Daedric quests.
Shivering Isles is definitely worth getting. It is the biggest, and most involved addon. It gives you a big new land to explore, lots of side-quests, new monsters, new weapons and armor, new things to summon, etc... It is definitely top on the list of extras. Do not hesitate to get it!
KOTN gives you a new questline to play out, a new faction to join, and a very cool new set of armor/weapons with the sword and board fighter in mind. Basically it is for your classic knight character. So not great for a magician, thief, or archer. It takes place in Cyrodiil, but does add a few new dungeons to explore during the quest.
The others are all kind of bland. Although I still have not gotten around to doing the Thieves Den yet, so do not count that one.
If you are playing on an XBox or PS3, Wizard's Tower is handy because it gives you spellmaking and enchanting altars. So you can use them without joining the Mages Guild. But if you are on the PC, you can just open the console and type in showspellmaking or showenchantment and get the same thing.
Fighters Stronghold gives you a castle, and a couple fights to go with it. If you are on the PC, you can find much better castles and quest mods at TES Nexus for free.
Vile Lair gives your vile characters a lair, including a free meal for vampires to snack on. Meh.
Spell Tomes adds in a bunch of books to the random loot that give you new spells. Not new spell effects mind you. They just took the vanilla spell effects and put them together in different ways than you see in vanilla spells. Nothing you cannot do yourself.
Orrery. Gives you a quest fighting bandits for a while, then a really neat planetarium to look at in the Arcane U. But once you stop oohing and ahhing over the neat gizmo, it just gives you a once a day power that varies depending on what time of the month it is. Since I never use powers like that, meh.
Horse Armor. If you have a horse, you can get two styles of armor for it. Looks snazzier, and your horse will live longer. So I would say a must for horse riders. Unless you play on the PC, where you can just set your horse to essential. But the armor still makes your horse look cooler...