For me it's between Skyrim and Portal 2. I love Minecraft as well, but I haven't played it much since 1.8 so for me its out of the running.
December 10th, 2011 skyrim might be awarded the game of the year award. do you think it should? and if not, what game is better in your opinion?
The fact that you have a specific date suggests you're referring to a specific site or award show?
gameplay wise no way. No keybind hotkeys, many bugs, overpowered perks, bad lvl scaling. You have to adjust difficulty by urself by not using most created stuff and limiting your gameplay.
Quests and graphics are more intresting than in wow example. Wow should learn that 300 quests with depth is more instresting than 3000 quests with quickgrind 2min grind.
You're on the PC I assume? Favorite the items/spells you want to hotkey, then open the favorite bar, hover your mouse over something, and hit a number between 1-8.