Ive been playing the fallout game (now the GOTY) for a while, other than The PiTT(which I just started, im done with all other quests and missions) I am at 80% on all the PS3 Trophies. I cant seem to get the silver tongued devil trophy. I have ran a good(as much as i can) hero character, I have done all the DLCs from the GOTY edition. I checked with the internet and they suggest I go to Knock Knock and repeat telling her that her jokes are funny and I can get the trophy. But mine wont allow me to do it?

I have done 25 successful speeches , so Im half way there, but I dont know where in the heck to find 25 more??? Maybe in the Pitt?? I doubt it?

I have tried

Vera at Rivet City
knock knock - at little lamplight
evan king - arfu
folks around - megaton
cant find pappy or bittercup at big town

those are just a few that i have tried for more or repeating speeches for the trophy, can anyone help me figure this out ???

i also need to know if i go back and do the neutral or bad karma characters for those trophies, will my 25 good hero speeches stack for the trophy?
in other words, will my 25 good hero speeches be added on to my bad character 25 speeches to give me a total of 50 for the trophy? or is it 50 per character?


help? iam trying to finish all the trophies before new vegas comes out, hehe

thanks

here is the list - http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Fallout_3_speech_challenge

btw...make sure you save before the challenge then reload till you get it

oh im maxed out on EXP at 30

thanks i try to use the list. do know if knock knock is patched in the GOTY edition? iv heard it is?

they patched lots of stuff, but to be honest i had no issues getting this trophy, the hardest imo is the data miner.

i hear ya , i have all the trophies, except 4-6 of the karma ones,( i need to be more normal and bad at levels 4,15,20 or whatever?, heh) the 3-4 of the PiTT ones then i will plat the game.

i tried knock knock and it didnt work for me, so maybe they fixed it?

on the karma ones save your game 1-2 levels before each required point and then reload and kill a ton of people or steal lots of items until you are neutral or evil.