How is Bethesda supposed to pull of a unknown character of unknown race six skill and age to suddenly become the emperor? The emperor generally speaking is a rather public figure, books will be written about him/her, people will talk to him/her, I just don't see this happening...
Not unless their is some kind of mantling involved. But even then, one of Talos his greatest achievements is leading and creating the Empire, it would be hard to mantle Talos without doing the same thing.
Well, one solution would simply be to avoid mentioning the guy in later games. We don't even know who Titus Mede II's father was, if he had children, if he had a wife, if he had siblings. While these are certainly people who would be recorded, (and whose absence would be noted) they go unmentioned.
Though I don't really see it as very likely. My guess is that we'll either get a reasonable exit for the dovahkiin in a expansion (i.e.the CoC) or his disappearance will be handwaved. (Nerevarine by rumor, Daggerfall agent by fan [censored])