I've got a ring and necklace that say they improve Smithing 12% each. I've not seen any evidence they work at all. Or rather, how they work. Are they supposed to increase my Smithing level 12% each? Or by 12 levels?
I tested it by forging items with and without the gear, and there was no difference in weight, damage or value. I then improved the items both with and without the gear equipped, and again, no difference in their stats. I only have the Steel perk right now.
After reading on the UESP pages, it's possible I happened to test the enchantments at a level where they didn't offer any benefit, so I need to retest.
Are these working for everyone else? And does "+12%" really just mean +12 levels to Smithing skill?