» Mon Nov 16, 2009 7:57 pm
Maybe it's just me, but right now, the soldier class seems significantly blander than the other three. Medics are... well, medics, operatives are sneaky assassin/hacker types, and engineers can create their own mini-bases wherever they please (or rather, where the enemy team lets them). They all have distinct, fleshed out roles, whereas the soldier is just... a dude with guns. Who tosses ammo around. And carries a few more grenades than other classes.
Maybe that thing that Chant suggested way back on the first page, giving soldiers the ability to wield weapons one step ahead of their weight class, would help make them more distinct? That is, have light soldiers be able to use a medium primary weapon and a light sidearm, have medium soldiers be able to use heavy weapons as a primary, have heavy soldiers be able to use two heavy weapons, etc. Sure, they don't get anything unique, like the ability to lay mines or disguise themselves, but now they're "that guy that you REALLY need to watch out for, because he's got way more bang for his buck in terms of body type and weapon type than you do" rather than "that guy with the same guns as us who tosses ammo around and sets charges at pre-determined points, whatever." Of course, you shouldn't get it right off the bat - something that powerful definitely needs to be purchased.
After all, the whole point of the soldier is that he's the backbone, front line fighter of your team, right? He might not have any skill in computers, or medicine, or engineering, but he's way tougher than everyone else. If his only purpose is to man the front lines and kill kill kill, (with the occasional buff, I know I know), shouldn't he be better at it than the other classes? Even a medic, a character who seems considerably more docile than a brutish soldier, is capable of whipping out a minigun and turning your character into a meatless skeleton... just like a soldier. It just seems wrong to me that someone who focuses more on handing out medicine can, more or less, wield the same firepower as a soldier (given their weight classes match).