I still don't get this stance.
I am more than just Agility, Endurance, Intelligence, Luck, Personality, Speed, Strength, and Willpower. I am a human being. I am not just numbers and statistics. I don't see why roleplaying would ever rely on numbers in relation to these attributes. If I'm roleplaying as a stupid but strong Nord, I don't need numbers to tell me he has a low intellect but great strength. That's just how he is, and he displays this through his actions and behavior rather than by statistics.
Right, and Skills are less of a statistics than Attributes? ah so in real life I can measure my Sword mastery and archery skills? or how well I can sneak and cast spells is that it? mmk heres a heads up since people keep focusing on the "numbers" and "statistics" bit.
Its a game, your roleplaying, doesn't effect the character, as it stands you can pretend your wood elf is strong as an Ox, but the -game- isn't going to magically recognize this, your character is in the -game- and he/she/it abides by the -games- rules, "thinking" something does not translate utterly into the game, What point are your actions and behaviors if the game is still going to "immersion break" your character out of context when the character makes an eloquent response of question during the game outside of your control eh? your characters strenghts and weaknesses need to be detailed to you, this isnt 2022 where the game has seamless organic increases and decreases and everything you do matters as well as being able to tell at a glance what the character is capable of from their muscular or lean build, and I don't see how a steroid injection that is perk tech tree where the character suddenly is able to preform a task out of the blue is any more organic than Attributes.
There is no "new" system, all we have are vague statements about how attributes are "in there somewhere" like really? does anyone not see the folly in that statement? anyway Dragon born already linked an on going discussion that got ON TRACK instead of bickering whats better perks or attributes, when that isnt even the case.